Close Menu
  • News
  • Features
  • Summer Game Fest 2025 Coverage
  • Guides
  • Previews
  • Reviews
  • Gaming News
  • Entertainment News
  • Tech
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
X (Twitter) YouTube RSS
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
The OuterhavenThe Outerhaven
  • News
  • SGF 2025
  • Features
  • Guides
    • Elden Ring Nightreign Guides Hub
  • Previews
  • Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Anime & Animation Reviews
    • Comic Book & Manga Reviews
    • Films & TV Reviews
    • Tech Reviews
    • Tabletop and Card Game Reviews
    • Toy Reviews
  • Gaming
    • PlayStation
    • Nintendo
    • Xbox
    • PC Gaming
    • Retro Gaming
    • Tabletop
    • Virtual Reality
  • Entertainment
    • Anime & Animation
    • Comic Books & Manga
    • Films & TV
    • Original English Light Novels DB
    • OELN DB
    • Culture
    • Books
    • Toys
  • Tech
  • Podcasts
    • A-01 Podcast
    • Nintendo Entertainment Podcast
    • Spectator Mode Podcast
The OuterhavenThe Outerhaven
Home»News»Gaming News»Which Elden Ring Nightreign Character Should You Pick?

Which Elden Ring Nightreign Character Should You Pick?

Which Nightfarer is the fairest of them all?
By Andrew AgressFebruary 14, 2025
Elden Ring Nightreign network test

As you may have heard, players had a bit of trouble with the Elden Ring Nightreign network test today. And not the combat kind, either. Rather, the servers went down. Only a lucky few—of the lucky few who got selected for the test—got to actually play co-op. But some players, including yours truly, got to at least try out characters offline.

The Elden Ring Nightreign network test has four characters that players can choose from for now. The full game will have eight when it arrives in May. In the meantime, players can choose between Wylder, Guardian, Duchess, and Recluse.

Which one is right for you? Let’s help you decide. Here’s an overview on each with some analysis to help you find the right one for your playstyle.

Wylder

Elden Ring Nighreign Wylder

Wylder is a generalist character with balanced stats across the board. This is the standard character players will start as when joining the network test. He has two skills, Claw Shot and Onslaught Stake. Claw Shot shoots a grappling hook to draw smaller enemies close to you—or bringing you closer to bigger bosses. Onslaught Stake launches an attack with a large explosion.

Wylder is a bit of a jack of all trades, master of none. He doesn’t have any of the more specialized moves of the other characters and therefore doesn’t excel in any particular area. He’s ideal for beginners, especially those who have never played a FromSoftware game before like Elden Ring or Bloodborne. That said, since Elden Ring Nightreign encourages picking up gear on the fly, experienced players can still tailor the build.

Guardian

Elden Ring Nightreign Guardian

Our next Nightfarer is Guardian, the dedicated tank of Elden Ring Nightreign. He has high defense and excels at crowd-control (and crow-control, hopefully). Players who don’t mind getting up close and personal with bosses or mobs will likely flock to him. Oh, and did I mention he’s a bird person?

Fittingly, Guardian’s two skills both involve sprouting wings. Whirlwind has him whipping up a cyclone to send enemies flying. Wings of Salvation is his divebomb attack. In Elden Ring Nightreign, “attacking” fallen allies will revive them. As such, Guardian can use Wings of Salvation to kill two birds with one stone—or two stones with one bird. The area of effect can devastate an enemy while bringing an ally back to life. I imagine we’ll see a lot of Guardian this weekend as the tank that holds teams together.

Duchess

Elden Ring Nightreign Duchess

I’ll say it now, Duchess is for the Bloodborne sickos. (Elden) Lord knows when we’ll see a proper sequel. But Elden Ring Nightreign shows that FromSoftware hasn’t forgotten about its gothic horror game. Duchess plays light on her feet like a Hunter, and even resembles Lady Maria from The Old Hunters DLC. Unsurprisingly, Duchess is all about evasion and speed, getting hits in quickly before pulling off several consecutive dodges.

Though slightly slower than Bloodborne builds (faster than anything in Elden Ring), Duchess has two skills all her own. Restage sees her use a pocket watch to repeat the couple of seconds of damage against an enemy. What does this mean? If you or an ally unleash a devastating attack, you can duplicate it. On the other side of the spectrum, she has Finale, a stealth skill that makes her and nearby allies briefly invisible. This has a wide range of uses from buying time to revive an ally to sneaking past an enemy to getting the drop on a boss from behind.

Recluse

Elden Ring Nightreign Recluse

Last but not least, we have Recluse, our spellcaster. Naturally, she specializes in ranged magic from afar. She has two skills, SoulBlood Songe and Magic Cocktail. Soulblood Songe is a blood chant that brands nearby enemies, allowing you and your teammates to siphon health from them, which is a great tool for when going up against bosses. Meanwhile, Magic Cocktail allows you to collect affinity residues to create a unique spell. But what does that entail exactly?

Recluse works a bit differently than the other Nightfarers due to her Magic Cocktail skill, which is more complex, but integral to her gameplay in an exciting way. Since Elden Ring Nightreign is all about finding materials in the field, Magic Cocktail makes Recluse into MacGyver. She can siphon elements—magic, fire, lightning, and holy—and combine three into one spell with its own effect. These can do anything from damage or damage negation to buff stamina or healing.

What’s more, siphoning restores FP, so you don’t have to worry about running out, assuming you managed to get the Magic Cocktail skill off. Whereas the skills of other characters are more like bonuses, this one is key—but incredibly versatile for players with good memories or a penchant for chaos.

The downside to the Recluse is that like all spell casters in Elden Ring, starting out she is extremely vulnerable and doesn’t have great defense or health.

Elden Ring Nightreign Decisions to Make

So which character should you pick? As of now, that really depends on your playstyle. Once the network test is up and running properly, we’ll see which characters people gravitate towards. And of course, you can change characters between runs.

It’s worth noting that the full game will also have four more characters, so preferences may change. At the same time, since this is a network test, FromSoftware may tweak Nightreign’s characters before release.

We’ll see how things play out this weekend and once Elden Ring Nightreign arrives in its full form for PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, and PC. It comes out on May 30th, 2024.

Elden Ring Elden Ring closed network test Elden Ring: Nightreign Fromsoft Fromsoftware
Avatar photo
Andrew Agress
  • Website
  • X (Twitter)

Andrew comes from the majestic land of New Jersey (the part that doesn't smell). A big fan of sketch comedy, he writes and performs it whenever possible. He gets his powers from listening to indie folk music and drinking aloe water.

Related Posts

Virtua Fighter 5 R.E.V.O. 1.04 Patch Released – Replays Aplenty

More Nintendo Switch 2 Records Revealed For The US and Japan

Sony Admits To Monitoring Nintendo Switch 2 Success

Atelier Resleriana: The Red Alchemist & The White Guardian Gets First Look

Code Vein II Hands-Off Preview at SGF 2025

Mortal Shell 2 Brings Faster Combat, Bigger Worlds, and Guns to the Soulslike Experience

Latest Posts

Virtua Fighter 5 R.E.V.O. 1.04 Patch Released – Replays Aplenty

June 15, 2025

The Evil Within Deserved More: A Great Horror Series Left Behind

June 15, 2025

More Nintendo Switch 2 Records Revealed For The US and Japan

June 15, 2025

Sony Admits To Monitoring Nintendo Switch 2 Success

June 15, 2025

Atelier Resleriana: The Red Alchemist & The White Guardian Gets First Look

June 14, 2025

Code Vein II Hands-Off Preview at SGF 2025

June 14, 2025

Mortal Shell 2 Brings Faster Combat, Bigger Worlds, and Guns to the Soulslike Experience

June 13, 2025
About Us • Our Team • Contact Us • Privacy Policy • Review Policy • Ethics Policy 
Work With Us • Reviews on Open Critic • Reviews on CriticDB
Copyright @2025 The Outerhaven Productions

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.