Close Menu
  • News
  • Anime Expo 2025
  • Features
  • Guides
  • Previews
  • Reviews
  • Gaming News
  • Entertainment News
  • Tech
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
X (Twitter) YouTube RSS
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
The OuterhavenThe Outerhaven
  • News
  • Anime Expo 2025
  • Features
  • Guides
  • Previews
  • Reviews
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Anime & Animation Reviews
    • Comic Book & Manga Reviews
    • Films & TV Reviews
    • Tech Reviews
    • Tabletop and Card Game Reviews
    • Toy Reviews
  • Gaming
    • PlayStation
    • Nintendo
    • Xbox
    • PC Gaming
    • Retro Gaming
    • Tabletop
    • Virtual Reality
  • Entertainment
    • Anime & Animation
    • Comic Books & Manga
    • Films & TV
    • Original English Light Novels DB
    • OELN DB
    • Culture
    • Books
    • Toys
  • Tech
  • Podcasts
    • A-01 Podcast
    • Nintendo Entertainment Podcast
    • Spectator Mode Podcast
The OuterhavenThe Outerhaven
Home»Features»The Game Awards is Fine With Expansions and DLCs Being Eligible for the Game of the Year Award

The Game Awards is Fine With Expansions and DLCs Being Eligible for the Game of the Year Award

By Keith MitchellNovember 16, 2024
Game Awards Show Logo

One of my frustrations with various video game award shows, as I mentioned recently during Spectator Mode Podcast Ep. 168, is that these events often exclude game expansions from the Game of the Year selection. It’s no surprise that I was captivated by the release of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree earlier this year. It’s all I wanted to play, and even with so many games available today, I still find myself jumping back in to play. Yet, no matter how amazing this expansion was, it would never be recognized for anything more than an expansion and would inevitably be overlooked during these award shows.

However, things are about to change if the upcoming The Game Awards has anything to say about it. According to an updated page on its website, The Game Awards has amended its prior stance on expansions, remasters, and DLCs.

The Game Awards aims to recognize the best creative and technical work each year, irrespective of the format of that content’s release. Expansion packs, new game seasons, DLCs, remakes and remasters are eligible in all categories, if the jury deems the new creative and technical work to be worthy of a nomination. Factors such as the newness of the content and its price/value should be taken into consideration.

What does this mean? For games like Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree or Final Fantasy XIV, which have seen several amazing expansions released over the past few years but were overlooked for GOTY, this change now gives them a chance to earn that coveted designation.

Of course, not everyone is thrilled about this decision and has taken to social media to voice their frustration—which, in my opinion, is a bit silly. It’s very silly.

Take these examples from the Twitter user, Nintendo Prime, who seems frustrated with the recent change to The Game Awards Show part.

Game of the Year shouldn't include expansions

Game of the Year shouldn't include expansions 2

By his reasoning, DLC should have its own category for recognition. Or should it be excluded simply because it’s not long enough? If that’s the case, should there also be criteria stating that a game must meet a minimum number of hours to qualify? That would disqualify several games from eligibility.

Consider this: in 2021, the Game of the Year at The Game Awards was It Takes Two, a game that can be completed in 12 to 15 hours. Meanwhile, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree can take up to 25 hours—or even longer if you’re tackling all the bosses instead of just the required ones and hunting down gear.

Is it fair to dismiss a DLC or expansion as a GOTY contender, even if it’s arguably the best game released that year—or even in years? To me, it’s not. That’s a prime example of gatekeeping 101. If a game is worthy of being a GOTY contender, it should be included—it’s that simple.

Being upset because a DLC or expansion they don’t like might win, or worse, beat out a game they want to win, is frankly ridiculous. This mentality seems rooted in the same console wars drama that the industry still struggles to move past. Let’s be honest—if a game won “Best DLC” or “Best Expansion” of the year, it wouldn’t carry the same prestige as “Game of the Year.” On top of that, it would likely compete with categories like “Best Ongoing Game,” leading to even more confusion.

In my view, it doesn’t matter. If a DLC or expansion adds substantial new content, fundamentally changes the game, and delivers an entirely fresh experience for players, why shouldn’t it be considered? Complaints about this feel like unnecessary outrage. The Game Awards’ decision to allow DLCs or expansions to be selected for GOTY doesn’t guarantee they will win—it just opens the door for deserving entries.

We don’t even know which games will be nominated yet, so maybe it’s best to step back and wait. The nominees will be announced on November 18, 2024, at 9 AM PT / 12 PM ET. If Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree or Final Fantasy XIV: Dawntrail earns a spot, it will be because they deserve it. It’s that simple.

Keith Mitchell - Headshot-PS_Gear_400x400
Keith Mitchell
  • X (Twitter)
  • LinkedIn

Keith has been a fan of geek culture and video games ever since his father gifted him his first gaming console many decades ago and has used this love of for the genres to start The Outerhaven. Keith keeps follows on the ongoings of videogames, anime, comics and technology, and while he has been writing about these topics for the past 14 years, he has been a gamer and tech guy for 30 years.

Related Posts

Top 7 Disney Characters That Should Be in Kingdom Hearts 4

Doctor Who is now Doctor Who Cares Anymore

Exciting Beat ‘Em Ups Releasing in 2025

Interview: Chris Berman Talks Ra Ra Boom During PAX East 2025

What’s the Point of a New Xbox Console Anymore?

Football Manager 25 Cancellation: A Hole Left in my Heart

Latest Posts

Anime First Reaction: GaCen Shoujo to Ibunka Kouryuu

July 6, 2025

Manga Review: I Made Friends with the 2nd Prettiest Girl in My Class Vol. 1

July 6, 2025

Manga Review: My Special One Vol. 10

July 6, 2025

Anime Expo 2025: Azuki Announces Our Aimless Nights Print Edition

July 6, 2025

Anime Expo 2025: Solo Leveling: Karma Game Announces for PC and Mobile

July 6, 2025

Anime Expo 2025: TOKYOPOP Announces Seven New Licenses

July 6, 2025

Anime Expo 2025: Denpa, Kuma Announce Six New Releases

July 5, 2025
About Us • Our Team • Contact Us • Privacy Policy • Review Policy • Ethics Policy 
Work With Us • Reviews on Open Critic • Reviews on CriticDB
Copyright @2025 The Outerhaven Productions

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.