When Mark Freedman first discovered Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – the self-published comic book created in 1984 by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird – he knew he’d found something special.
At that time, in 1986, after a decade of working in the toy industry, Freedman was just starting his fledgling licensing company Surge Licensing, and he was on the hunt for an emerging brand he could shepherd. As it turns out, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – about four crime-fighting, sewer-dwelling reptile brothers named Raphael, Michelangelo, Donatello, and Leonardo – was just what he’d been looking for.
“Eastman and Laird spun a story that was just incredible, and the characters would align themselves perfectly with action figures,” Freedman says today. “I was sold pretty much the second I saw it.”
Once the three men joined forces, toys were just the beginning of the soon-to-skyrocket Turtles franchise. By 1987, a TMNT cartoon was airing on television screens across America. After the cartoon came a video game, which was followed by a live-action, record-breaking motion picture. Soon, the likenesses of Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello could be found on products of all kinds, from lunchboxes, piñatas, and pinball games to roller skates, skateboards, and snow skis.
For the past 35 years, Freedman – nicknamed “The Fifth Turtle” for his decades-long dedication to the Heroes in a Half-Shell – has held on to examples of all of this Turtles merch, as well as TMNT comics, prototypes that never made it into production and a variety of products manufactured exclusively for international markets. The items represent more than three decades of memories and symbolize the work that went into turning an obscure comic book into a pop-culture phenomenon.
But, as Freedman says, “sometimes you have to purge a little bit.” This is why, on Feb. 3, Heritage Auctions will proudly present Mark “The Fifth Turtle” Freedman Showcase Auction, featuring more than 200 lots from Freedman’s personal collection of TMNT treasures.
The sale also features a sealed copy of 1994’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Tournament Fighters, which has long been considered one of the rarest NES games in the Turtles franchise – if not the rarest. This game also has a Wata grade of 9.8 A++, which is effectively the highest grade one could hope to receive from Wata, and it’s only the third factory-sealed example ever offered in a Heritage auction.
Collectors will also clamor for a binder filled with contact sheets from the 1990 TMNTmovie. The album, which Freedman says not only rekindled fond memories of making the film but also “brought a little bit of a tear to my eye,” includes a variety of black-and-white shots of various characters and scenes from the movie.
But it’s the toys in the sale that Freedman considers the most special. “I’m a toy guy at heart, and being able to turn your idea or inspiration into an actual action figure is the ultimate high in the toy industry,” he says. “And having it be successful is the second. It’s not an easy thing to accomplish.”
As Freedman already knew, building a global brand requires hard work in the best of circumstances, but when the property you’re trying to promote stars four martial artist turtles who are also teenage mutants, you have an even bigger battle on your hands.
“No one really understood it,” he says, recalling his many TMNT pitches to the usual-suspect toy companies. “I was turned down everywhere. Everyone said no except for this one toy company called Playmates, and no one had ever heard of Playmates. But when I brought them Ninja Turtles they immediately got it.”
Admittedly, the Turtles weren’t the typical toy heroes. They had no superpowers, for one thing, and beyond that, they had human foibles and tastes, including a particular fondness for pizza.
“They weren’t necessarily the strongest but had to work as a team to overcome adversity,” Freedman says of the Turtles.
But he just as easily could be talking about the Surge Licensing-Playmates partnership. While both teams started out as underdogs, they put their all into the Turtles, eventually transforming TMNT into a multibillion-dollar property that lives on today. In 2008, Viacom (owner of Nickelodeon) bought the Turtles franchise, reimagining the brand in a variety of ways. The Turtles’ future looks bright, too: In 2023, Seth Rogen’s production company Point Grey Pictures, alongside Nickelodeon Animation Studios, is set to release a CG-animated movie starring Michelangelo, Donatello, Leonardo, and Raphael.
And it’s all because an up-and-coming licensing agent saw the potential in an underground comic book and was hopelessly devoted to it from day one. “This was a labor of love. I put my heart and soul into it,” Freedman says. “There were days and days when I didn’t sleep. It was that kind of an effort to make this happen.”
But happen it did because, as the world would soon discover, you can’t keep a good Turtle down, not even an honorary fifth one. Now generations of fans – and generations to come – can enjoy the lovable heroes who, to some, didn’t make much sense but, to countless others, made all the sense in the world.